whats your budget like for waders. I use breathables in the surf and have no problems with them. They allow me to move around like I was wearing regular clothes. The boot foot waders tend to leak faster then the stocking foot ones. I would recommend getting stocking foot waders and buy a cheap pair of wading boots just for the purpose of keeping your feet a little warmer in the winter, spring and fall you can get away with buying a cheap pair of tennis shoes to put over the stocking foot waders. I have a pair of simms chest waders which are breathable and also a pair of hodgemans which are cheaper, but I have not had a problem with yet. The hodgemans I have are not chest waders or hip waders, they are like a pair of pants with a belt. I had them for 4 years with heavy use and they don't leak yet. You will have no problem getting breathables on, as far as keeping warm, look for the ones that have 4 layers or more of fabric. I would suggest taking a trip to Cabela's to try on every option possible.