Hey Brijones,
I worked as a remarketing agent for an equipment leasing company a few years back and used to deal with title problems similar to yours almost every day.
There are 3 scenarios that I can come up with for you. I'm assuming that the title was filled out and then some portions were whited out by the Seller, not you.
Scenario # 1
DMV May take a written Bill of Sale from the Seller. It would have to have both Seller and Buyers signatures notarized.
Scenario #2
You would have to get a signed and notarized Title affidavit from the seller explaining why some portions were whited out and give an explanation as to why the corrections were made, ie: a previous buyer backed out of a deal to purchase the boat after the title had been filled out. Or whatever the reason, it needs to be explained in detail.
Example:
Title Affidavit
To NJ Division of Motor Vehicles
Re Year Make Model and Vin Number of the boat.
To whom it may concern,
This letter is to certify that the above referenced title was incorrectly filled out and portions were then whited out by the seller ( his name ) This was done for the following reasons...
__________________________
Sincerely, Name of Seller
Signed in the presence of the notary
Scenario #3
DMV can be a pain in the arss and say no to both of the above and make the seller apply for a duplicate title, voiding the one you have.
Problem here is that when the duplicate gets mailed it will go to the seller, not you.
I would go to DMV and ask them exactly what they require you to do. Every one and every person you deal with can give a different answer.
I hope this helps you.....
If you have any questions drop me a pm
Kenny.