Irregardless of this fisherman keeping the fish or not. I have observed many cases of fisherman keeping illegal catches, I have done it in the past myself....but I realized very early on it was stupid and selfish. As a avid Fresh water and Salt water fisherman I learned to be concerned with good conservation practices, I taught my children the same. We have all seen the law beakers and poor sportsman I'm sure. So I made a possible mistake in assuming this guy kept an illegal ketch,only because he said he caught five fish....he didn't say he caught five fish but threw them back because they were to small or he kept only one, Just something I would have done, but doesn't mean everyone would do the same. WOW! hope I cleared that up.