Its unfair that the Raritan bay has been having split regulations. Its almost impossible to tell if you are in NY or NJ waters. The entire bay should have the same regulations. Sometimes I catch keeper fluke in NJ 18" and move on to the NY side 21 1/2". If I get checked by the dept of fish and game the only way to tell the difference between the fish I caught would be the little sweatsuits and gold chains on the Staten Island and Brooklyn fish.
I can say this because I am half Italian and grew up in Brooklyn. So fogetaboutit.