World Record Fluke Caught today (8/17/2007)!

[CapBob]

I have found that many ladies are outstanding fisherman. For the last two years the fairer sex has taken top honors on my boat for biggest bass and fluke.

When you consider the percentages of each sex that fish, I believe the ladies have the edge as far as being skillfull anglers. By far the majority of ladies that fish are more serious sportsman, compared to a smaller percentage of men. (on a whole)

Not putting the stronger sex down, but it is what it is

[Luna Sea 5]

Better her (a real fisherperson) then some lucky stiff on a party boat with a rental rod who can't even spell fluke!

I have to agree with this as well

[Capt. Ed]

Great point!

Capt. Ed

[Ruger314]

just to add to the pot.. her cousin works on a dragger.. look close at the fish and the tail area,

alot of talk how this unrolling to be a false catch!

[Capt. Ed]

Hi Guys,

An expert on fish inspected in Saturday.

Why so much skepticism?

Also, because she has another World Record (I believe), she must have known how much scrutiny would be placed on this event ...

How about a big congratulations until the IFGA certifies it or not ...

How about calling out Capts. that fish spots they were given without so much as a Thank-you! Two major catch reports on this site that yours truly helped and still nothing ... the Sea Girt Reef spot was my lead ... there - I said it. Man did I screw that up for myself ...

Congrats again Monica,

Capt. Ed

[Fishonw/Ron]

Just got off the phone with the IGFA buddy of mine and no filings or word yet on the fluke. I will keep you posted.I heard the reason the gills are torn was because in order to officially weigh it she needed to rip the bucktail out. This could take time to confirm . She does have a good track record and she is a known local angler. I hope it works out for her . It definetly makes you feel like you too can catch a record fish like that one in our backyard.
It is a bad picture and alot can be pointed out against her but IGFA will decide. At some point the Captain of the boat she was on should step up to the plate and back her up???
Fish On... at the very least you now know they are out there..net or hook

[Duffman]

  I just cant buy it.  If I'm totally wrong on this, I'll stand corrected BUT, how many pics of fluke have you seen?  Hundreds of thousands?  When have you seen a fish that beat up from a rod and reel catch?  Scales missing, bloody tail, bones almost poking through the skin toward the head.  I've had fish sit in a bucket for 24 hours that didnt look that beat up.

[brijones1]

  I just cant buy it.  If I'm totally wrong on this, I'll stand corrected BUT, how many pics of fluke have you seen?  Hundreds of thousands?  When have you seen a fish that beat up from a rod and reel catch?  Scales missing, bloody tail, bones almost poking through the skin toward the head.  I've had fish sit in a bucket for 24 hours that didnt look that beat up.

maybe it fell out of the truck on the way to get it weighed in 

[Flukedood]

  I just cant buy it.  If I'm totally wrong on this, I'll stand corrected BUT, how many pics of fluke have you seen?  Hundreds of thousands?  When have you seen a fish that beat up from a rod and reel catch?  Scales missing, bloody tail, bones almost poking through the skin toward the head.  I've had fish sit in a bucket for 24 hours that didnt look that beat up.

maybe it fell out of the truck on the way to get it weighed in 

Maybe it wouldnt fit in her car and she had to tie it to the bumper and drag it in..
 

[Fishonw/Ron]

I agree its not gonna be easy for her...I agree when you see a doormat you cant help but caress it into the net and jump for joy.On top of that fluke live a long time out of the water this looks like its been out of water for 2 days..My personal opinion and I hope Im wrong the fish looks like it was frozen and thawed or even salted hence the bones showing through the skin. Its all good and gives us a healthy debate.. . One guy said why isnt she happy in the picture. I know I would be

[ped579]

As far as this angler is concerned the IGFA will have the last say and till then I have no reason to doubt Monica. 

Like Capt. Ed said she is a seasoned angler who has dealt with the process before.  Why put her other record in jeopardy for a what?

Happy Catching

Paul

[IrishAyes]

I personally question the quality of the camera being used for the picture more than the fish.  I have had fish put in my cooler that are red on the white side and tail when we take them out to clean them.  As far as the head being pulled away, someone mentioned that she had to take out the spro.  I don't know if that is a fact or not.  But just the massive weight pulling down on that fish would probably cause damage to the neck area.
I don't know why people have to be so sceptical when events like this happen.  Everyone is throwing things out there that are 'what ifs' and 'could be's'.  When there are facts reported and not assumptions, then we can make an informed conclusion.
Just my two cents.

[Fishonw/Ron]

I agree Captain Joe I hope she gets it. It will benefit the the sport and the state of NJ in some way. I think we are all just having a little fun with this. 

[mckee17]

My first impression upon seeing the picture for the first time was - How could a seasoned angler who has a potential world record fish have let its condition deteriorate to that extent??  A fresh caught fish reasonably well cared for just doesn't look like that.  I hope that I am all wet on this, however I can't help but be skeptical.

[ped579]

 

[Capt. Ed]

Hi All,

Here are the facts:

1. There is a fish. Not too many people have ever seen a fish like this ... commercial or recreationally caught.
2. It was weighed and exceeds the current All Tackle World Record at an IGFA Certified Weigh Station (Scott's).
3. It was caught on a private boat with someone on-board!
4. She has successfully filled out the parperwork before.
5. The paperwork (including photos) takes time to complete and file.
6. It has been inspected by a marine Biologist.

All other stuff being thrown around is heresay.

For the millionth time ... congratulations Monica!

She is certainly the "best" (measured by size) Flounder Fisherman this year (Winter and Summer)! Frontpage article to follow ...

Instead of knocking one of our own, why don't we put a positive light on this. Many people from around the country (especially the East Coast) will be reading these threads in the days to come.

[IrishAyes]

Capt Ron,  I agree that it may help the sport and NJ if it is certified.  I don't agree that we are having fun with it.  When push comes to shove, people are out and out calling her a liar and cheat. I wouldn't call that having fun.  Perhaps I am taking it too seriously, but, I know I certainly wouldn't want people thinking and talking that way about me if I were to be fortunate enough to accomplish something like that.  And I am certain that anyone who is bashing this lady would not want that to happen to them either.

[Hotrod]

I say Good for her.  but also it's ok to be a tad skeptical,  Like a detective.  right Joe.  you need to consider all possibilities..

A mild debate It the most

I say good for her.  but I sure would have taken care of that baby better   Like a million dollar check..

[Fishonw/Ron]

Does anyone know what type of endorsements if any can come from a fish like that? I gotta believe some good sponsors will be calling her to endorse. Like Rod said a mild debate is good for the boards on a rainy day or should I say rainy week...

[Capt. Ed]

Hi All,

Rod - I disagree. I do not question any catch that someone claims. That would be calling them a liar.

Unless there is a technical issue (were the rules of the IGFA were not followed) no one should be skeptical until the law is involved.

Folks - if this fish was not caught by her, she is open up for fraud and other charges.

Think about that ...

Capt. Ed